Tithes Are Foodstuffs - ( Agrarian based ), Not Money !
One error concerning tithing by churches today is that tithes are not in the form of money.
Wherever you read or hear of tithe in the scriptures, it is about foodstuffs or increase of land, or seeds or livestocks.
GOD never accepted money for tithes.
If the tither could not carry the food items, because of the journey to the place of tithing, he could sell them.
But at the place of tithing, he had to buy food items with the money for the tithing.
God has not changed this rule anywhere in the scriptures. He said in Malachi 3:6 before talking about it in the next verses that,
“For I am the LORD, I change not...” So, why are people taking money for tithes?
If anyone still insists that believers should pay tithes, they should follow GOD'S instructions. The GOD'S tithes are in the form of foodstuffs. Any tithe in the form of money is man’s invention, and not GOD'S.
Every scripture in the Bible concerning tithes talks about foods. When the scriptures mention tithes, its taking about foodstuffs. Tithes are in the form of foodstuffs, and should never be paid, used or applied in the form of money.
When the Lord Jesus even rebuked the Pharisees and the Scribes concerning tithes in Matthew 23:23, He did not mention money. He knew that tithe was not money, so He mentioned mint, anise and cumin, and not money. He didn’t say they ‘pay tithe of every mite or cent’.
The only scripture where GOD allowed tithes to be exchanged for money was Deuteronomy 14:24-26. But at the place or time of payment, the tithe should still be foodstuffs.
In Deuteronomy 14:24-26, GOD ordered that if the place to give the tithes was far, and to carry the foodstuffs was difficult, the tither should sell the tithes, which are foodstuffs, for money. But if the tither reached the place where the tithes were to be paid, he should turn the money back into tithes, that is, foodstuffs, once again, before he would give or pay it.
In Leviticus 27:30, 32-34, GOD clearly specified the items He described as tithes, and His and holy unto Him.
He said, “the tithe of the land, whether of the seed of the land, or of the fruit of the tree, is the LORD’S: it is holy unto the LORD. And concerning the tithe of the herd, or of the flock, even of whatever passeth under the rod, the tenth shall be holy unto the LORD.
“He shall not search whether it be good or bad, neither shall he change it: and if he change it at all, then both it and the change thereof shall be holy; it shall not be redeemed.
“These are the commandments, which the LORD commanded Moses for the children of Israel in mount Sinai.”
So if a believer still thinks, he would pay or give tithes, he should give or pay foodstuffs. Any other form, apart from foodstuffs, is not tithe. If you call money tithes, you have created something for yourself to serve.
And any pastor or church, who collects money as tithes is doing something God has not commanded. The church or pastor cannot be of GOD.
A Christian should give freely-willingly, wholeheartedly and cheerfully, he doesn’t give by measure (or) for blessing.
ABRAHAM GAVE “TITHES OF ALL”
The first mention of tithe was in Genesis 14:20, and it was in connection with Abraham. He gave it to a priest called Melchizedek out of the spoils of war.
This tithe was not from Abraham’s farm produce or his yearly increase. The spoils included “goods” or gold, silver and other precious substances and “victuals” or foodstuffs, herds and flocks. (Genesis 14:11)
The scripture in Genesis 14:20 said “he gave him tithes of all”. The “tithes of all” could only refer to the herds and the flocks. Because the king of Sodom told Abraham to give him the persons and take the “goods”, that is, the gold, silver and other precious substances, after Abraham had given tithe to Melchizedek. Abraham’s answer to the king was that he would not take a “thread” or “shoelatchet” from the spoils, except what the men who went with him had eaten and their portion.
This means that, what Abraham gave to Melchizedek were from the “victuals” or from the herds and the flocks, and excluded the “goods” or the gold, silver and the other precious substances.
What is more important is that Abraham’s giving was of pure love or freewill. It was from his heart. Nobody asked him to give, neither did anyone specify or suggest any percentage for him or tell him the measure to give.
Abraham gave it by faith, that is, by the principle of grace. GOD helped him to defeat his enemies, and if God had so blessed him, he also had to bless Him back by giving tenth of the blessing to His priest from his heart free-willingly and at his own discretion. He chose to give him ten percent, from which tithe was derived.
If any person demands that believers give ten percent, it cannot be freewill or one’s discretion or a principle of grace. And so it cannot be of faith, but of law.
A law specifies what the lawgiver demands, failure to meet the demand or a default means punishment. A law enslaves, binds and intimidates. And it punishes. A law does not give the practitioners the choice or chance to decide by themselves or show or do what their hearts tell them in a freewill manner.
If you are paying any money by faith, as the patriarch father Abraham did, then it should be by your own percentage, or measure or by your own discretion, and not a specified ten percentage. And it should not be a demand or come with an instruction that if you do not give tenth faithfully, you are cursed with a curse.
THE DANGER OF LIVING BY A LAW
GOD, by the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, is not dealing with anyone by law, but by grace. Anybody who is under a work of a law is under curse.
Because nobody can obey all the law of God. (Galatians 3:10) And a default in one point of the law, is default in all the points. (James 2:10)
But if GOD is dealing with you by grace, and not by law, why do you want to serve or please Him by works of law?
Paul said to the Galatians that they were foolish, because they turned to works of law, [after] they had been made to see how CHRIST was crucified for their sakes; to receive the Spirit of GOD and ministration of HIS miracles by the hearing of faith, and not by the works of the law. (Galatians 3:1-5)
Paul told them the reason why Christ was crucified on the tree. He said, if one was crucified on a tree, it meant that the one was cursed by the law. So Christ had redeemed us from the curse of the law for been made a curse for us, that the blessing of Abraham might come upon the Gentiles through Jesus Christ, and the promise of the Spirit through faith. The Lord Jesus Christ was cursed for our sakes by the law, that we Gentiles or non-Israelis or non-Jews could receive the blessing of Abraham through Jesus Christ, and the promise of the Spirit through faith. (Galatians 3:13-14)
The blessing of Abraham and the promise of the Spirit come upon Gentiles through Jesus Christ and faith in Him, and not through payment of tithes or fulfillment of a work of law as the Jews. So why should a Gentile go back to the days of Abraham or to the Jewish laws to fulfill them for blessings and promises?
Is it only an ignorant, a deceived and a foolish person who will do that..?
But there is a consequence, and a costly one, for such an ignorance, deception and foolishness. Such a person cannot receive healing, deliverance from the powers of darkness, peace from oppression's, prosperity, power and victory of the world and eternal life that Christ gives freely to those who believe in Him.
The scripture says, “Christ is become of no effect unto you, whosoever of you are justified by the law; ye are fallen from grace”. (Galatians 5:4)
If Christ becomes of no effect unto a person or if one falls from grace, that person is even worse than an unbeliever. And it is what becomes of a believer who follows a work of the law.
Tithing is a work of the law, because it specifies an exact percentage, and not one’s own freewill measure.
Again, defaulting in payment or paying it unfaithfully has a consequence of a curse.
All Christians who practice tithing are under the curse. By this single practice, all these ignorant people have denied themselves the grace of Christ, including healing from the diseases that are in the world, freedom from oppression's of demons and witches, peace and prosperity, the Holy Spirit and eternal life.
Christ dwells in a believer. So the healing, blessing, victory, peace, prosperity, protection, provision, righteousness, salvation and eternal life that are in Christ are in the believer. If the believer continues to believe, out of his or her belly would flow rivers of living water as He said in John 7:38.
But, if he discontinues to believe and turns to the works of the law to justify himself, he makes the Christ stagnant and ineffective, unable to flow out to overcome the world and the deficiencies of the flesh to set him free.
Live by the Christ, and not by your own works, and you shall be blessed to give freely from your own measure even higher than Abraham’s tenth.
The works of faith are not the works of the law.
They are the believers’ deeds that come from the abundance of grace.
We can only please GOD by the works of faith that come from what we have abundantly received from the grace. Nobody can please GOD by the works of the law, because the law is not of faith. (Galatians 3:11-12) The Jews under the law were NOT obligated to give 10% of their incomes! This simple fact alone is enough to destroy the un-scriptural doctrine that GOD DEMANDS you pay 10% of your income or be cursed.
The Bible does not anywhere indicate that tithing is applicable or expected in our time at all.
It was a system which was brought in following the exodus from Egypt and the forming of the children of Israel into a nation of their own.
Their nation was divided into 12 tribes, and 11 of these tribes grew crops, had animals, inherited land etc. The twelfth tribe, Levi, were the priests and administrators of the nation, and had no land, animals, crops etc, so the 11 tribes had to give the tribe of Levi 10% of their income. This mathematically works out that they were then all equal, because from this part which was given to the tribe of Levi, they still had to make their own offering of a tenth to GOD, the same as the other tribes had to. (see Numbers 18:25-39)
Money was rarely, if ever, the thing tithed in the Bible. [Nehemiah 13:10-13] To be truly biblical, tithing was NOT based on your income or money AT ALL! [Deuteronomy 14:22-23, Deuteronomy 18:1-5, Deuteronomy 26:12 , Nehemiah 10:38-39, Nehemiah 12:44, Leviticus 27:30-33, Joshua 13:14] Pre-law tithing was voluntary and profit based and law tithing was mandated and land based (agrarian). Agrarian means "of the land," and agrarian tithing was based on what you were able to produce from the land, plants or livestock.During the period of the Mosaic Law, GOD commanded people bring a tenth of what they produced from the land regardless of the income they received from it. Tithing wasn't income based BEFORE OR AFTER the law and the tithe was NOT money! In fact, it was against the law to sell the tithe. One was to bring the PRODUCT, not what the product was worth. [Leviticus. 27:28] There are many references to tithing the "increase" [Example: Deuteronomy 14:22 using the Hebrew tbuw'ah] which literally means fruit or produce and in the tithing verses EATING the tithe is often referred to. Note in Nehemiah 13:10, the Levites went to THE FIELD to replace missing tithes. During the time of agrarian law tithing bartering was common but there were also MONEY SYSTEMS in place. [Genesis 23:15-16 and Genesis 42:25, Jeremiah 32:9-11, Deuteronomy 14:25 and Malachi 3:5] Yet the tithe remained agrarian (land based).